house02

House MD: Stories Worth Watching

I’m not a big fan of stories. In fact, I lost my interest in stories a long time ago. I easily get bored when I’m exposed to a story, so much so that I would rather read an article on a subject that I don’t like at all than read a story – real or made up by someone. I like to learn things, I want people to say what they have to say as directly as possible, and I’m not interested at all if all they have is a pretty little story.

It was sad that all required reading were novels when I was in school; we were left, perhaps unintentionally, to think that book equals novel, and reading equals reading stories. I still remember how thrilled (and mad against my past teachers) I was when I first discovered that there are other things to read than stories: books on science, philosophy, art, design… A treasure carefully hidden by education.

For a long while now, my rule on stories when it comes to reading has been pretty strict and simple: I don’t read stories. But it gets a little more complicated when it comes to visual storytelling. For one thing, watching is easy – stories aren’t worth the effort of reading, but I can watch them alright when I’m too tired or too bored. Plus, I get kicks out of good tricks of visualization as a visual thinker. For one reason or the other, I have watched some TV series like 24, Lost, Fringe, Two and a Half Men and How I Met Your Mother. They all were little doses of entertainment in days of work or boredom; and with time, I lost interest in all of them. I couldn’t imagine what it was like to be a “fan” of a TV series until I hit upon House MD. It was different.

 

 

I was introduced to House MD by my girlfriend who said “You have to watch this, there is a guy who thinks like you and another who looks like you!” But these personal identifications aren’t the only reason why House MD is so special in my view – there is an objective one. Amongst all the shows I watched and I know of second-hand, House MD has a special condition. It isn’t an all-embracing mythology like the others. A hardcore intellectual standpoint, a strict worldview is described, even advocated in House MD. It eliminates all old/new sanctities from religion to humanism; touches all the hot spots from free will to love, from death to polygamy with a physicalistic and evolutionistic approach; it mocks all conformist courtesies and habits. Believe it or not, episode by episode it piles a complete modern philosophical system with its ontology, epistemology and ethics. Considering how subtle the implementation is, this show fits into one of the definitions of good art as far as I’m concerned; stories of philosophy and science.

But can good art also be a popular culture item? To my surprise, House MD does all this within the popular culture: everybody loves it. I’ve never seen someone who doesn’t. And why is this interesting at all? As I said before, what House MD does is to proudly present a radical worldview – that I personally embrace – to the public, and that’s why I’m so interested in what people think of it. I’m pretty sure that nearly none of those people around me who “absolutely love” House can tolerate the worldview presented in the show. These are all regular people who say “Bless you” when somebody sneezes, or believe in the sanctity of human life. I’ve heard “House? It’s awesome!” from such people that I wondered if we were watching the same show. Something doesn’t add up.

One possibility is that they are not aware of what they’re watching and that all they understand from the show is how “awesome” Gregory House is. This doesn’t sound plausible to me because it is the very same philosophical and social standpoint I described that makes House who he is. Another probability is that they notice the intellectual blizzard going on but this doesn’t trigger anything in their minds apart from House becoming as cool a character as Barney Stinson; it is all cast aside as a tool used for the dramatic unfolding of the episode. Either way, all these people continue to watch House MD as if they’re watching How I Met Your Mother, and to perceive it at the level of “who did what to whom” – the level of story that I despise.

Either position seems tragic to me. I’m still waiting to meet a clever, honest and coherent person, interested in more than the story, saying “I watched House MD, they have good stories and interesting characters but the worldview presented there bothered me, so I’m not a real fan of it”. I’m not that naive to expect everyone to think on what they watch, but, I mean, nobody? Not one?

 

Addendum

Years after writing this, I’ve just watched the How I Met Your Mother episode ‘Something Old’, where Ted Mosby confesses:

Maybe it’s dumb to look for signs from the Universe. Maybe the Universe has better things to do – dear God, I hope it does. Do you know how many signs I’ve gotten that I should or shouldn’t be with somebody, and where has it gotten me? Maybe there aren’t any signs. Maybe a locket is just a locket, a chair is just a chair. Maybe we don’t have to give meaning to every little thing. Maybe we don’t need the Universe to tell us what we really want. Maybe we already know that deep down.

A lot of unnecessary ‘maybe’s, but more power to the writers!

4 Comments

4 Comments
  1. I watched it for the first 2 seasons, I really liked it. but not the way you do. It wasn’t the story either. I think I liked the characters, not only G. House but some others too. But at some point I got a little bit bored and that was because of the storyline through the episodes. It became too obvious. I mean, that’s probably the same thing with most of the series but that happened to me. I know a lot of medical students (one of them is my best friend) having House nights and watching them all together. They turned it into a guessing game, they start to watch and guess what may be the cause of the disease etc. and they say that they usually find the cause 15 minutes before House does :))

    I don’t know if you ever watched this but, if you like really absurd comedies (I find it absurd enough)(not absurd like monthy phyton though) I would strongly suggest “Weeds”. It goes around “stories” but I find it quite amusing and probably the best comedy tv show around. even though I’m not a big fan of comedies.

    • Thanks for the reply, I was going to show this post to you myself because I was wondering your opinion both as a story person and as one of the House lovers around me.

      What you say is reasonable; I remember myself getting bored at one point for the same reason you did, but I kept going thanks to the philosophical stuff I mentioned, and they got better at that with time. I think the scenarists also realized what they were good at and worked on that. Thanks for being one of the people I was waiting to meet. =)

      I remember you mentioning Weeds, I’ll check it out when I have time.

  2. Hej,

    I mostly agree with you about the philosophical stories behind House M.D. I also enjoyed a lot when House is stuck in his mind and couldn’t move on. after all he found a way how to deal with not controlling everything. (still in my mind, move on House, sometimes you have to move on.. )

    I remember tremendously inspiring episodes of house M.d. and would like to advice some other good series:

    Spaced
    Black Books

Leave a Comment

Join the conversation.

Leave a Comment

DMCA.com Protection Status © 2017 Deniz Cem Önduygu